Open 24/7 Call
Guide · Updated October 23, 2026

Original or aftermarket car key: which should you buy?

Aftermarket keys cost less and many work fine. Originals cost more and avoid a few headaches. Here's what we've learned from using both.

Short answer
  • High quality aftermarket keys are a good value for many cars.
  • Originals cost more but match the car exactly.
  • Cloned keys copy an existing key. They start the car, but remote buttons can misbehave when both keys are used.
  • For smart keys we usually recommend the original.
  • Cheap online keys are the most common source of failed programming.

What's the difference?

An original key comes from the car maker's supplier. An aftermarket key is made by another company to work with the car. Quality ranges from excellent to useless.

Cloned keys

Some keys are made by copying the data from your existing key instead of adding a new key to the car. Both keys start the car and open the doors by keyless, but the remote buttons can act up when both keys are in use. We've tried both approaches and generally recommend adding an original key properly.

When aftermarket is fine

  • Plain transponder keys and many remote keys
  • Older cars where originals are expensive or discontinued
  • A budget spare

When we suggest the original

  • Smart keys on newer cars
  • Models where aftermarket keys are known to be unreliable
  • Cars that accept only original keys, such as some Hyundai hybrids

Warranty

Original keys we supply are covered for 3 years, aftermarket keys we supply for 1 year, and our programming for 3 years. Keys you supply aren't covered. See warranty terms.

Written by the Keyhub Locksmith team, a mobile car locksmith in Marietta, GA. Updated October 23, 2026.

FAQ

Questions on this topic

Are aftermarket key fobs reliable?

Good ones are. Cheap ones often fail to program or die early.

Is a clone key bad?

It works for starting, but remote buttons may misbehave if both keys are used. We prefer adding a new key properly.

Get a price by text

Send the car and what you need. We reply with a price, usually within minutes. Day or night.

Send as text

Text or call · 24/7(470) 469-1578

Open 24 hours, 7 days a week. We are mobile: the key is made and programmed where your car is parked, at home, at work or on the road. We speak English, Spanish and Russian.

keyhubllc@gmail.com · Keyhub LLC · Marietta, GA · mobile service only
Open 24/7 · (470) 469-1578